NFL Mock Draft Simulator with Instant Pick Grades
The fastest NFL draft simulator with real-time A-F letter grades for every pick. Analyze value, team fit, and performance instantly.
Configure Your Draft
Round 1 • Pick 1
Loading...
Available Prospects
Your Picks & Grades
Your picks will appear here
Recent Picks
Recent picks will appear here
Team Grade Leaderboard
How The Grading System Works
Value Score (40%)
Measures pick value vs player ranking. Drafting #1 prospect at #1 = perfect 100.
Need Fit (35%)
Analyzes if pick addresses critical team needs. Top needs get highest scores.
Reach Analysis (25%)
Identifies steals vs reaches. Major steals boost grade, reaches lower it.
Grade Scale
Elite Pick (95-100)
Perfect value filling major need with top talent
Strong Pick (85-89)
Good value addressing team needs
Average Pick (70-79)
Acceptable but uninspiring selection
Failed Pick (<60)
Major reach ignoring critical needs
More Draft Simulators
Standard Mock Draft
Team needs & BPA drafting
Fantasy Football ADP
Average draft position trends
Fantasy Projections
Weekly & season-long projections
Team Name Generator
Instant fantasy team names
Fantasy Cheat Sheet
Draft-ready rankings & tiers
Fantasy Rankings
QB, RB, WR, TE & FLEX
Trade Analyzer
Evaluate fantasy trades instantly
PFN Mock Draft
Pro Football Network style
PFF Mock Draft
Pro Football Focus style
Fantasy Trade Analyzer
Evaluate fantasy football trades with advanced metrics
Mock Draft with Trades
Trade calculator & pick swaps
Multi-Round Simulator
Complete 7-round draft experience
PFF Mock Draft Simulator
Analytics-driven draft predictions
PFN Style Simulator
Pro Football Network format
Fantasy Draft Practice
Dynasty, Rookie, Superflex modes
Team-Specific Mock Drafts
Practice mock drafts tailored to your favorite team's specific needs, draft position, and roster gaps.
Understanding NFL Draft Grades
Our NFL mock draft simulator with grades uses advanced algorithms to evaluate every pick across multiple dimensions. Unlike simple ranking systems, we analyze draft pick value, positional need fit, and reach/steal analysis to provide comprehensive letter grades that mirror professional draft evaluations.
The grading system helps you understand not just who you drafted, but whether you maximized value at each pick. Perfect for fantasy football managers preparing for rookie drafts or NFL fans who want to grade their team's real draft day decisions.
How Draft Pick Grading Works
Every pick is evaluated using three key metrics that combine to create your final letter grade:
Value Score (40%)
Compares player ranking to pick position. Drafting the #1 prospect at #1 = perfect value. Drafting #20 prospect at #5 = poor value.
- A: Rank within 3 spots of pick
- B: Rank within 8 spots
- C: Rank within 15 spots
- D/F: Major reach (15+ spots)
Need Fit (35%)
Analyzes if the pick addresses critical team needs. Each team has priority positions based on roster gaps.
- High Need: Top 3 priority positions
- Medium Need: Depth positions
- Low Need: Already strong areas
- Luxury: Unnecessary position
Reach Analysis (25%)
Identifies steals and reaches. Getting projected 2nd rounders in round 3 = steal. Reaching for 4th rounders in round 2 = bad value.
- Steal: 10+ picks later than rank
- Fair: Within 10 picks either way
- Slight Reach: 10-20 picks early
- Major Reach: 20+ picks early
Grade Scale Breakdown
Understanding what each grade means helps you make better draft decisions:
Elite Pick (95-100 points)
Best player available who perfectly fills a major need at tremendous value. These are franchise-changing picks that typically involve drafting a top 3 player at their actual position while addressing your biggest weakness.
Excellent Pick (90-94 points)
Outstanding value meeting a clear need. You drafted a top prospect at the right spot who improves your roster significantly. These picks rarely bust and often become starters.
Strong Pick (85-89 points)
Solid value with good need fit. You got a quality player who should contribute immediately, though perhaps not the absolute best available or perfect need match.
Good Pick (80-84 points)
Reasonable value that makes sense. Not a home run, but you addressed a need or got good value. These picks work out more often than not.
Average Pick (75-79 points)
Acceptable but uninspiring. You reached slightly or drafted a position you didn't desperately need. Not a disaster, but better options likely existed.
Below Average Pick (70-74 points)
Questionable value or need fit. You either reached significantly, ignored glaring needs, or passed on much better prospects. These picks often lead to regret.
Poor Pick (60-69 points)
Significant reach or luxury pick when critical needs exist. You drafted someone 20+ spots ahead of their ranking or ignored multiple position needs.
Failed Pick (Below 60 points)
Disaster pick. Major reach for a player with no need fit while elite prospects were available. These are the picks that get GMs fired.
Draft Strategy for Better Grades
Maximize your draft grades by following proven strategies that balance value, need, and positional scarcity:
- Best Player Available (BPA) in Round 1: Don't force need picks early. Elite talent beats need fit in the first round. A+ grades require top prospects.
- Address Needs in Rounds 2-3: Middle rounds offer the best value for need picks. You can still get starters while filling gaps.
- Avoid Major Reaches: Never draft a player more than 15 picks ahead of their consensus ranking unless it's a QB in need. Reaches kill your grade.
- Hunt for Steals: Players who fall 10+ spots are grading gold. If a first-round talent drops to the second, your grade soars.
- Position Scarcity Matters: Thin position groups (QB, EDGE in 2026) justify slight reaches. Deep groups (WR, RB) punish reaches heavily.
- Balance Your Board: Don't draft the same position three times in four picks unless you're rebuilding. Diversity improves your overall grade.
- Watch Tier Breaks: Know when talent tiers drop off. Drafting the 5th best WR vs the 12th best is huge—even if it's only 7 picks different.
Team Needs by Position
Our grading algorithm evaluates need fit based on realistic 2026 NFL team needs. Here's how positions affect grades for common team situations:
High-Need Positions (Boost Grades)
- QB for QB-needy teams: Highest need weight. Elite QBs can overcome slight reaches and still grade A.
- EDGE for pass rush starved teams: Premium position that justifies top 10 picks. Major need multiplier.
- OT for weak O-lines: Protecting franchise QBs is critical. Left tackle picks grade higher than right tackles.
- CB for secondary-weak teams: Elite corners are rare. Top 15 picks for CB1 needs grade excellently.
Low-Need Positions (Lower Grades)
- RB when you have a starter: Luxury pick that grades poorly unless generational talent (Barkley-level).
- QB when you just paid one: Drafting a QB with a recent extension is an F unless injury replacement.
- S when CB is the need: Safety is the least premium secondary position. Draft corners first.
- Any position drafted 3x in 4 picks: Over-drafting one position tanks your overall grade balance.
Famous Draft Grades in NFL History
Looking at how real NFL drafts graded out teaches valuable lessons about draft evaluation:
A+ Grade Examples
- Colts - Peyton Manning (1998, Pick 1): QB-needy team, best player available, generational prospect. Perfect value at perfect need = textbook A+.
- Chargers - LaDainian Tomlinson (2001, Pick 5): Elite RB to run-heavy offense with RB need. BPA + fit + team identity = A+ grade.
- 49ers - Nick Bosa (2019, Pick 2): Dominant EDGE to defense-first team with desperate pass rush need. Elite value + huge need = A+.
- Bengals - Joe Burrow (2020, Pick 1): Heisman winner QB to team with worst record and QB vacancy. Can't grade any higher.
D/F Grade Examples
- Browns - Johnny Manziel (2014, Pick 22): Character concerns + reached 15+ spots while elite players available. Massive reach for need = D grade.
- Raiders - JaMarcus Russell (2007, Pick 1): Reached for workout warrior over proven Calvin Johnson. Wrong evaluation + bad process = F.
- Jaguars - Blake Bortles (2014, Pick 3): Major reach (projected 15-25) for QB need over Khalil Mack. Desperation pick = D.
- Bears - Mitchell Trubisky (2017, Pick 2): Traded up, reached over Mahomes/Watson, poor evaluation. Trade cost + reach + miss = F.
Grading Lessons
- Elite grades require consensus top talent + team need alignment
- Reaching more than one round ahead rarely works out well
- Trading up for need picks often results in lower grades (overpay + reach)
- The best drafts balance BPA in Round 1, needs in Rounds 2-3
- QB picks get graded on a curve due to positional importance
Start Grading Your Draft Now
Get instant letter grades for every pick with our advanced grading algorithm. Perfect your 2026 NFL Draft strategy today.
Your Complete NFL Draft Grading Resource
Whether you're preparing for draft night or evaluating your team's actual picks, our NFL mock draft simulator with grades provides the most comprehensive and realistic grading experience available. With instant letter grades, detailed breakdowns, and a dynamic team leaderboard, you'll master draft evaluation like a pro.
Explore our other tools including standard mock drafts, simulators with trade calculator, and fantasy football draft practice!
Entertainment & Educational Use
Images courtesy of Wikimedia Commons under Creative Commons licensing. NFL team marks are property of the National Football League and respective franchises. All odds data aggregated from licensed sportsbook APIs. Educational use only.